ورود | نام نویسی |  درباره کابل پرس | تماس با کابل پرس نسخه موبایل  Home | Login | Register | About Kabul Press | Contact | RSS | Twitter | Facebook | Mobile Version

 کابل پرس من | حقوق بشر | آزادی بیان | افشای اسناد | دیدگاه | ببینید و بشنوید | عکس | کارتون | فرهنگ | گزارش | English

Home > English > Opinion > U.S. Troops Unaware Koran a Holy Book?

U.S. Troops Unaware Koran a Holy Book?

No prosecution for burning 100 Korans

Sunday 2 September 2012, by Matthew J. Nasuti (Former U.S. Air Force Captain)

U.S. military members in Afghanistan did not know that the Koran was a holy book. That was the preposterous excuse put forward last week by Brigadier General Bryan G. Watson, who investigated the burning earlier this year at the Parwan Detention Facility of approximately 100 Korans. He recommended against any prosecution of the officers and soldiers involved. General Watson stated that U.S. officers and troops were only given a one-hour briefing on Islam and he determined that the briefing did not convey to them that the Koran was a holy book. They therefore did not know that it was an insult to Islam to burn the Koran!

This sham investigation was solely designed to shield the Pentagon from criticism. A seemingly hapless Watson was unable to identify anyone to blame. No one was responsible for the book burnings or for the feeble training or for fielding military units that were dismally unprepared to undertake their missions. How could detention facility officials ever hope to obtain information from Islamic extremist prisoners if they were unaware what Islam was?

The key point that General Watson repeatedly made in his report was that he “absolutely rejected any suggestion” that there was any intent to disrespect the Koran or defame Islam. Watson somehow concluded that it was impossible that anyone could even suggest an anti-Islamic motive. The Pentagon determined that U.S. troops are so uncultured and uninformed that they are incapable of any sophisticated criminal motives. The report raises more questions than it tries to answer. If Watson is correct, how could the Pentagon ever hope to defeat the Taliban with such an uneducated and seemingly witless expeditionary force? Watson’s report insults the reputation of U.S. forces and tries to insult the intelligence of its readers.

At one point, Watson vaguely blames the problem on “a lack of cross-talk between leaders and commands.” He blames the incident on mistakes, however the facts reveal that U.S. officials were warned by their Afghan counterparts not to burn the Korans and they went ahead anyway. Watson also revealed that the plan was to burn 474 Korans but only 100 were burned before Afghan employees intervened and halted the practice.

No one expected an honest investigation and they were not disappointed. Truth does not have to be the first casualty in warfare, it is only a casualty when dishonorable officials are appointed to wage the war. We also learned this week from a SEAL Team 6 expose’ entitled, “No Easy Day” that the May 2011 raid that killed Osama bin Laden was a kill mission. Contrary to President Obama’s May 2011 press conference, bin Laden did not make any move toward a weapon and was not an apparent threat to anyone. The new book revealed that bin Laden poked his head out a door into the hallway and was promptly shot in the head by the SEALs. The SEALs did not know at the time that they had shot bin Laden. They had been ordered to kill everyone. When the SEALs discovered it was bin Laden, he was lying on the floor still alive. They then proceeded to finish their prisoner off with several additional shots. Apparently executing wounded prisoners is now acceptable under the rules of war.

It has taken more than a year to learn the truth. The motives of the White House in concocting a false cover story for the kill mission are not clear. The President was apparently embarrassed about aspects of the raid.

The Watson report and “No Easy Day” are just the latest in a long line of examples of a just war being dishonestly presented. Whether it is the squandering of USAID and commander’s emergency response program (CERP) funds, or the rising number of Taliban attacks, or the growing insecurity in the countryside (especially in formally safe provinces such as Bamyan), or the increasing danger of “green on blue” fragging attacks on U.S. troops; the lack of honesty from Pentagon officials has reached record levels. Like Diogenes searching for an honest man, this reporter is still searching for an honest Afghan war assessment from anyone in the Pentagon.

Within the U.S. military, generals like to quote from the fortune-cookie sayings of Chinese military philosopher Sun Tzu, including his famous saying that one must understand the enemy in order to defeat him. If U.S. officers and soldiers have no knowledge of Islam, and do not even know what the holy Koran is, how far does their ignorance stretch? General Watson’s plan was to protect the Pentagon, but his report reveals a shockingly uninformed and poorly trained military. It details that the U.S. military is deploying bodies to Afghanistan, not troops competently trained in counterinsurgency. The pre-deployment training is cursory and superficial. It is warfare waged on the cheap. A poorly manufactured product tends to produce poor results, which is why the Afghan war is the Taliban’s to lose, not America’s to win. Eleven years of warfare in an Islamic country and the Pentagon claims that U.S. troops still lack even a rudimentary understanding of Islam. Wars have been lost due to less.

Also in this section

Forum posts

  • The Koran Is A "Holy Book"?
    Who knew? I, perhaps naively, believe that a "Holy Book" (never to be "reformed" at that: for is it not Allah itself?) should not demand of its adherents (in the 21st Century, no less) that the "other" (including, of all people, Muslim women) should: be slaughtered, oppressed, humiliated, singled out, conquered, raped, dominated, cursed, minimized, stripped of their common humanity, isolated, deprived of basic education, held hostage to pre-medieval scientific enquiry and process, stripped of free-will and freedom of conscience, ruled by religious despots whose mind-set has not left the Seventh Century, denied medical care (polio vaccines in Afghanistan and Pakistan, for example), denied music and art, forced to marry (often to first cousins, causing many genetic ills, including cognitive/intelligence decline) have their clitoris’ amputated (to deny pleasure and enforce male domination) be required to dress as "walking coffins", walk "three paces behind", be minded, watched, followed, etc. by male family members, stoned to death, crucified, beheaded, have limbs amputated, denied movies, television, alcohol (particularly even in moderation), etc. Well, the list could go on forever.
    It strikes me that the Koran is a somewhat problematical "book", essentially impossible to understand, or to advocate, except by the brainwashed.

  • Leave your bigoted lies somewhere else.
    In some countries they just kill the person (140,000) a year.
    Rape takes place one every 7 seconds.
    Waiting to see you mature.

  • To Uzoozy: Are you directing your comment to me, or the author of the article?

  • This is preposterous. Soldiers are trained to kill people and break things. Any other training not specifically designed to take and hold objectives and win campaigns is a waste of time. I hope they never know any more about the Koran than it is the holy book of the enemy. The Generals seem to have no problem burnings bibles.

  • Angry? Bitter that Americans would not give YOUR holy book more respect than Muslims give OUR holy book - which they have burned, confiscated, and torn up. Heck, we shouldn’t give more respect to the Koran than is given to Christians in Muslim countries - where they are kidnapped, raped, beaten, burned alive, and killed via the most horrifying means.
    Tough. Their job is to provide military assistance. They do that. They do that, even with the restricting Rules of Engagement (ROE) that they have been forced to follow.
    You don’t like it? Too bad.

    View online : http://rau.3littlefoxes.com

Any message or comments?

Who are you?
  • Log in
Your post
  • To create paragraphs, just leave blank lines.

Add a document


Kamran Mir Hazar: Editor-in-Chief / Email: editor at kabulpress.org

Copyright: 2003-2013 The Kabul Press: News, Discussion& Criticism | Afghanistan Press

کليه ی حقوق محفوظ و متعلق به سايت کابل پرس (افغانستان پرس) می باشد.