Reporters Without Borders
said today it fears that impunity will prevail in the
case of Zahra Kazemi, a photo-journalist with Canadian
and Iranian nationality who died a year ago (on 10 July
2003) in Baghiatollah hospital in Tehran after being
beaten while in detention.
"We suspect that the
senior Iranian officials implicated in this murder will
remain unpunished and that a scape-goat will be
convicted in order to put an end to a case that is
embarrassing for the regime," the organisation said.
"We nonetheless hope
that the trial due to take place on 17 July will shed
full light on this killing and that our Canadian
section, which is still awaiting visas, will be able to
attend as observers," Reporters Without Borders said.
The organisation called
on the Iranian authorities to allow Kazemi's lawyers to
participate in preparing the case for the trial as
required by Iran's constitution and international norms,
and it reiterated its call for the repatriation of her
remains to Canada, as requested by her son, for an
independent autopsy.
Aged 54 and normally
resident in Canada, Kazemi was detained outside Evin
prison, north of Tehran, on 23 June 2003 as she was
taking photos of the relatives of detainees. Beaten
while in detention, she died from her injuries just over
two weeks later. After initially trying to cover up the
cause of her death, the Iranian authorities recognised
on 16 July 2003 that she was "beaten."
Kazemi's body was
hastily buried in the southern town of Chiraz on 22 July
2003, contrary to the wishes of her son, Stephan Hachemi,
a permanent resident in Canada who has French and
Canadian citizenship. Kazemi's mother in Iran publicly
acknowledged that she was pressured into authorising her
burial in Iran. Since then, the authorities have paid no
heed to the requests for her remains to be disinterred
and repatriated to Canada.
A commission of enquiry
to determine the circumstances of her death was set up
at President Khatami's request on 13 July 2003. In a
report released a week later, the commission said that
between the time of her arrest on 23 June and her
transfer to hospital on 27 June, Kazemi was interrogated
in turn by the staff of Tehran state prosecutor Said
Mortazavi, the police, the prosecutor's staff again, and
finally by officials with the intelligence ministry.
The report said the
skull fracture that caused her death occurred no more
than 36 hours before her hospitalisation at midnight on
27 June. According to the chronology of events
established by the investigation, the fatal injury could
have occurred while she was in the custody of the
prosecutor's staff or the intelligence ministry.
The report also said
that doctors in Baghiatollah hospital determined that
Kazemi was "brain dead" as early as 27 June, the day
that her family was told that she was in a coma in
hospital. The report did not explain why the doctors
waited until 10 July, the day after the anniversary of
the July 1999 student demonstrations, to officially
announce her death.
The military
prosecutor's office assigned Kazemi's case on 23 July
2003 to Mortazavi, but Mortazavi subsequently recused
himself because of the allegations that he was directly
involved in her death. The commission of enquiry had
established that he personally took part in an
interrogation session within hours of her arrest. The
case was transferred to Judge Esmaili at the end of July
2003.
After a wrangle between
reformist and conservative clans, which blamed each
other for Kazemi's death, an Iranian intelligence agent,
Mohammad Reza Aghdam Ahmadi, was named on 22 September
2003 as the suspected killer.
Judicial service chief
Mahmoud Hashemi Shahroudi and intelligence minister Ali
Younessi set up a committee at the end of December 2003
with the ostensible aim of reviewing all of the facts of
the Kazemi case. The real aim, however, was to find a
compromise. Shahroudi said at the time : "The important
thing is not who killed Zahra Kazemi. Whether an agent
with the intelligence ministry or a member of the Tehran
prosecutor's staff, it doesn't matter. What counts is to
name a suspect."
The Iranian judicial
authorities rule out any question of state institutions
being to blame and accuse Ahmadi of "almost deliberate"
murder. This is the point on which the Kazemi family
lawyer, Nobel peace laureate Shirin Ebadi, intends to
base her case in order to establish that the blow or
blows were inflicted on Kazemi with the intention of
killing her. Another lawyer, Mohamad Ali Dadakhah,
maintains that the court has no jurisdiction and that
the case should be dealt with by an assize court.
Dadakhah also reported
that a second person has been charged in the case. It is
Mohammad Bakhshi, an official at Evin prison. On its
official website, www.rouydad.info, the Participation
Front (President Khatami's party) had already claimed
that Bakhshi took part in Kazemi's killing as an
assistant to the Tehran prosecutor, Mortazavi.